The sad tale of Gary-Chip-Tiny Elvis-Squishy-Paws is the 9th episode of Nicky, Ricky, Dicky & Dawn of Season 1. It aired on 11/22/14.
When the quads get a new dog, they argue over which one gets to name it. Eventually, the 1st owner of the dog takes the dog back & the quads have a attempt to get him back.
The children argue over the name of a dog who stopped crime at Get Sporty. After that, they start fighting over what they should name the dog. Finally, a wealthy woman claims the Harpers' dog as her own & the children have to get the dog back. In the end, the children think of a fair way to decide between the dog's name choices; Squishy Paws, Gary, Tiny Elvis, Chip, & Lord Timothy. The dog ends up being named Squishy Paws, much to Dawn's delight, as that was her name idea.
Adian Gallagher as Nicky Harper